Sponsored Links #2 August 26th, 2005, 4:16 am Rustinpat . Why can't Snape get past his hat My Blog List. I trust Severus Snape. ... Why did Voldemort still trust Snape? Why did Snape and Dumbledore argue in HBP? Email This BlogThis! What kind of act could make Dumbledore … Third Year : Joined: 5716 days. As evil as he seemed, Severus Snape, wasn't actually a bad guy, as anyone who has seen all the Harry Potter movies knows. Ask Question Asked 1 year, 6 months ago. But lucius was a death eater and knew that it wasn’t sirius. I know that one of reasons is that Malfoy would be killed by voldemort but if they helped dumbledore to survive they could help Malfoy as well.Voldemort couldn't kill harry because he was hiding so they could hide Malfoy as well.And severus didnt need to be in voldemort's favor.They could just all survive. Why did Severus have to kill dumbledore? And in the sixth book we finally got an answer of sorts. Basically, Snape would have had no way of knowing that Voldemort was under the turban. Why did Dumbledore trust Snape? 4.) The fact that Snape was still such a bully, manipulative, and even cruel makes it troubling that Dumbledore was willing to trust and use him so much. there are many more reasons and if you want to know, read my source :D. oh and Michelle T. it's spelled Quidditch Discussion in 'Books' started by Nienor, Oct 16, 2003. The Harry Potter musical parody by Matt Lang, known as A Very Potter Musical, is nothing short of a laughathon.Therefore, it makes perfect sense that the relationship between Severus Snape and Albus Dumbledore is put through the prying eyes of a suspecting Harry Potter, who cannot understand why the headmaster would trust an ex-Death Eater so blindly. why did Dumbleore trust Snape for so many years even though he didnt expect Snape still l’amour Lily after all that time? Summary: Harry stops writing to the Order and Dumbledore sends Snape to check out why. In short, I believe that Dumbledore ’s trust in Severus Snape has its foundations in Snape ’s days at Hogwarts. . - Dumbledore was surprised to know Snape still loved Lily. Snape clearly hates children, hates people less intelligent than him and hates teaching those people. He believes that Snape had mended his ways and is loyal to him. Just borrowed. Disclaimer: Nothing you recognize belongs to me. We know that after Snape told VM about the prophesy, he … . - Dumbledore was surprised to know Snape still loved Lily. But here is my theory: Personally, I think Snape is good. 8 Letting Hogwarts be such a dangerous place. why did Dumbleore trust Snape for so many years even though he didnt expect Snape still 사랑 Lily after all that time? Why does Snape hate Harry? Why did Dumbledore trust Snape? But Snape changed side 17 years hace because pregunta and answer in the severus snape club Dumbledore wanted Snape to kill him because he didn't want Draco to have it on his conscience. Newer Post Older Post Home. Snape was dumbledores man through and through so there was no way that if dumbledore had not had asked snape to kill him, snape would never have gone through with the unbreakable vow. - Dumbledore was surprised to know Snape still loved Lily. While Dumbledore didn’t particularly like the reasons why Snape betrayed Voldemort, he did grow to trust him completely. Snape protects Harry and dies for him because he loved Harry's mother Lily. But Snape changed side 17 years il y a because question and answer in the Severus Rogue club He's never shy about expressing this fact either. Why Dumbledore Trusted Snape by sylvanawood. A big Thank You goes to my two wonderful beta readers, Maggie and Snarkyroxy, who patiently listen to my whinging, are both helpful and thorough, and always encouraging. Why would we even trust him? Last edited by Jessica; November 23rd, 2005 at 5:31 am. By: Corbin. If you’re not convinced, this list will do the trick – I’ve found the 15 top reasons why we should actually all hate Dumbledore… Dumbledore trusts Snape even though everybody thinks he is a Death Eater because Snape made an Unbreakable Vow with Dumbledore that he would protect Harry. Normally for Harry Potter the coming of the dawn brought hope to his thoughts. HARRY'S POV — I just couldn't understand why Lupin was taking Snape's side? Also, given Snape's nature, or past, Dumbledore needed or wanted to keep Snape close to him, at the very least to keep an eye on Harry Potter himself. 2.Why did Dumbledore need James’ invisibility cloak? Hot Network Questions Is it necessary to add "had" in past tense narration when it's clear we're talking about the past? Will be returned. Mentions of abuse.--Thanks again Molly for beta reading for me! We know now that it was a mistake for Dumbledore to have trusted Snape. 1.) These attempts on Albus Dumbledore's life were the events that led up to the Battle of the Astronomy Tower on 30 June, 1997. We will look at Dumbledore’ s relationship with Severus Snape and see why he trusts him. Plus, Snape was never the true master of the Elder Wand, due to the fact that Dumbledore, who was dying of a terrible curse, asked Snape to kill him when the time came. . However, why give him a teacher's job? 3.Why does Dumbledore trusts Snape? Definitely McGonagall seems more trustworthy than Snape to the readers but all the questions on Snape’s loyalty vanish at the end of the last book. Wilson or. Snape is welcome to stay, though. theweeflea | The Truth shall make you free! 2.) Previous Thread Next Thread. Location: Wisconsin. First, we need to know where Dumbledore was in his thinking about Voldemort, at the time Snape … Labels: Harry Potter. Then why did he made the Unbreakable Vow? Besides, Lupin said that Dumbledore trusts Snape. Why did Dumbledore trust Snape? What is wrong with her? As the books go on, little details are revealed about Dumbledore that suggest he might not be the kindly old grandfather he was portrayed to be at first. Why did Dumbledore trust Snape? Why did Dumbledore offer Licorice Snaps to Harry in GoF? - Dumbledore was surprised to know Snape still loved Lily. And Charisma. This theory begins with Snape’s overhearing of the prophecy. But Snape changed side 17 years 이전 because 질문 and answer in the 세베루스 스네이프 club Rating: PG-13. He also didn't know that Quirrell was attempting to assist Voldemort, and directly tells Voldemort in book 6 that he was trying to stop Quirrell to maintain Dumbledore's trust. It’ s a phrase that has echoed for five books and left us wondering. Can anyone tell me the reason(s) why he trusted him? Yes, Snape had killed Dumbledore, but what other choice did he have? His own life and Draco’s were at stake and Dumbledore wouldn’t have survived regardless. 3.) She knows everything happening at school. The most important question, for whom? . Yet, Dumbledore trusts him. The plot to assassinate Albus Dumbledore was a series of events that took place over the 1996–1997 school year at Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry. Snape is one of the few misunderstood people in the books, i think dumbledore trusts him because he has changed, why else would he help Harry and friends? We waited expectantly for the revelation that we believed was coming – why did Dumbledore trust Snape? This may have been brought up before...I'm new on the board so I'm not sure. Didn't think of that. why did Dumbleore trust Snape for so many years even though he didnt expect Snape still amor Lily after all that time? tantrix August 11th, 2004, 5:15 pm i guess i have shown more why Snape is good rather than why Remus and Dumbledore trusts him but these are reasons why they would have i think. But Snape changed side 17 years 前 because 質問 and answer in the セブルス・スネイプ club Share to Twitter Share to Facebook Share to Pinterest. Why Does Dumbledore trust Snape? 5.Where was baby Harry from the time his parents died to the time Hagrid picked him up? why did Dumbleore trust Snape for so many years even though he didnt expect Snape still 愛 Lily after all that time? This whole Snape good or evil question comes down to WHY Dumbledore decided to trust him. At this time he was still dedicated to Voldemort. So if Dumbledore was surprised at Snape still being in love with Lily what other reason could he have thought made Snape so trustworthy? My friend & I were just discussing Harry Potter 7, and we cannot remember the reason why Dumbledore trusted Snape throughtout all the books. 4.Why was the Potter’s home destroyed? Why did lucius lie to draco and why did snape act weird In the 3rd book draco said he'd want revenge if he was harry because draco thinks sirius told voldemort where the potters were. An Issue Over Trust. Draco?