Hungry Horse. In more recent times, heightened awareness of the dangers posed by the Hayward Fault led to several studies in the 1960s and 70s. "It's the looky-lous that are going to be the issue.". "The terrible consequences that would result from the bursting of this dam and the sudden rush, through the gorge below, of this vast body of water unloosed to instantaneously deluge the valley, can scarcely be conceived," the Tribune wrote. The report cites the dam's proximity to the Cascadia Subduction Zone. an independent forensic investigation found. We try to get out in front of our high-hazard dams.". But with drought conditions in the West, the lake currently holds about 3.5 trillion gallons (13.2 trillion liters) of water. ", (MORE: Oregon Launches Earthquake Alert System). When was the last time Lake Mead was at full pool? How far is Hungry Horse Dam from Glacier National Park? There are also three Native American reservations along the Colorado River that would be affected. The Hungry Horse Project is in the Flathead National Forest, Flathead County. The break forced evacuation of boaters, hikers and anglers along the American . A high hazard dam means if the dam were to fail, loss of life is likely. The dam and accompanying hydroelectric plant were built in phases and over the course of . Wouldn't minds intelligent and creative enough to put up such a structure be prescient enough to foresee and account for the problems that lie ahead? How Does One Convert Watts To Horsepower? It was a beautiful, clear Saturday afternoon in June when the Stillwater Dam gave way. a total of about a 5.6 billion kilowatt-hours are generated annually at Hungry Horse Dam, and the subsequent series of . Its vitally important that we get this information to the public, said Kern County Fire Chief Dennis Thompson. Map Information What is the 2 biggest dam in the United States? "It's a pretty self-reliant group in this part of the state," he said. Let's say the Hoover dam broke. The disaster wiped entire towns off the map and killed more than 2,200 people. The Hoover Dam concrete would cure in 125 years by conventional or natural methods. Flood waters hit northeast . The actual collapse of the dam would devastate a critical part of many global supply chains, resulting in massive shortages of many categories of goods. Fortunately no lives were lost, but 10,000 people were displaced or evacuated, more than 2,000 homes were damaged or destroyed, and tens to hundreds of millions of dollars in damages occurred. The Weather Companys primary journalistic mission is to report on breaking weather news, the environment and the importance of science to our lives. Rebuilding efforts are still underway. Terms of Use | Other damage could be expected, too, including some cracking of the main dam embankment. With winter rains on their way, officials worry a dam that creates a small lake 17 miles west of Redding could collapse . The 100-year flood plain (map above) covers significantly less area than that which would be inundated if the dam breached (map right). The name comes from a local legend about two horses, Tex and Jerry, that escaped and almost starved to . The explicit modeling of these two flood-specific characteristics, in addition to other general characteristics (e.g., construction class, occupancy, year built, etc. "Most of the people in Johnstown never saw the water coming; they only heard it; and those who lived to tell about it would for years after try to describe the sound of the thing as it rushed on them," historian David McCullough wrote in "The Johnstown Flood. A large earthquake, for example, could compromise some or all of the structure. Insurance coverage is one of the most effective ways of ensuring a region re-bounds quickly after disaster, but in the Oroville region flood insurance penetration is fairly low. Work continued through the early 1890s raising the dam another 10 feet or so and adding huge amounts of fill sluiced onto the dams embankment, which is about 1,000 feet thick at its base. The next meeting, held Oct. 16 at the Hampton Inn, will be a "table top" exercise, where managers actually run through a scenario of a dam failure. By Howard Jones. If people know about Chabot Dam at all, it's likely because Lake Chabot is the centerpiece of a popular regional park. The 564-foot Hungry Horse Dam and Reservoir are located 14 miles from Glacier National Park's west entrance. The state-backed National Insurance Flood Program (NFIP) recently extended until the end of September by Congress, dominates the flood insurance market, providing 95 percent of residential flood policies. A breach at Kerr Dam on the south end of Flathead Lake would be less disastrous than one at Hungry Horse, Stanley said. Effective flood defenses also make a crucial difference when assessing flood risk. Understanding flood risk and how it is correlated with wind exposure, is required for management of an overall book, risk tolerance and accumulations. That's enough to serve 1.3 million people. 1. We Finally Know Why Ancient Roman Concrete Outlasts Our Own, Special Offer on Antivirus Software From HowStuffWorks and TotalAV Security, 4 billion kilowatt-hours of hydroelectric power, How Evaporation from Lakes and Reservoirs Could Sustainably Power a Nation, Nevada and Arizona: Hoover Dam (U.S. National Park Service). The Bureau of Reclamation will have a meeting next month and in October to go over Hungry Horse Dam failure scenarios with local emergency management officials. "It's something we're really active with," he said. Winds light and variable.. Clear skies. The Hungry Horse project, dam, and powerplant are operated by the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation. One of the two dams at Isabella Lake collapses while the lake behind the dam is full. Get our monthly newsletter featuring listener questions not answered on the Bay Curious podcast. The first is an orientation meeting, scheduled from 9 a.m. to noon on Sept. 10 at the Hampton Inn in Kalispell, said Dennis Philmon, facilities manager for the Hungry Horse Dam. The most immediate damage would be caused by catastrophic flooding, damaging if not completely destroying many towns, cities, and Native American reservations in the surrounding states. "Do I need to buy a canoe? If Hungry Horse Dam breaks, here's where the water will go The probability that Hungry Horse Dam will fail suddenly and completely is on the order that Kalispell will be wiped out by an asteroid. Low 36F. Without sounding like an Oscar acceptance speech, on behalf of the team that worked on the model, I would like to thank the judging panel made up of representatives from the media and the industry for selecting our entry. Most property owners rely on the National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP), which is most commonly sold to homes in the 100-year flood plain along the Feather River. "But I was not expecting to see anything about a flood zone. The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, which operates Libby Dam on the Kootenai River, refused to release information for the same reason. The dam, which is the second largest in the U.S. poses a threat to eastern Montana and western North Dakota, including the Western Star city, if it were to ever fail. Failure at Pablo Dam would be much worse for Mission Valley residents, said Jolene Jacobson, coordinator of the Confederated Salish and Kootenai Tribes' Office of Emergency Management. Local agriculture would suffer from the loss of water, leading to the risk of mass starvation. An acre foot of water is a foot of water spread over one acre. The first was from 1933-1941 when the main dam and Left Powerhouse were constructed. "Since 9/11, a lot of things, a lot of information, has been considered sensitive," he said. The foundations of any dam can be compromised, and this is one of the most feared and dangerous types of dam failure. Within 10 hours, water would be 1-foot deep across most of Bakersfield deep enough to float a car and prevent people from driving to safety. No conventional bomb would have an effect on a dam like this. The release from the dam has raised the river, which runs between the two cities, by more than 5 feet. As well as accessing accurate flood hazard data, this also extends to data on flood defenses, the first-floor height of a building or the presence of a basement all key factors in assessing flood risk. Nine Ways To Tell The Difference. At RMS, we are developing tools to quantify these kinds of extended risks to allow the private flood insurance market to step in and fill the current gaps in coverage. "However, a breach would result in a potentially catastrophic flood if it occurred and risk is high enough to warrant immediate actions. This flood plain is shown as blue areas in this map. Now, if 3.5 trillion gallons of water were suddenly set loose, it would certainly wreak havoc on everything in its path. Most domesticated horses in the world today are used to ride and to do farm or ranch work. Dams are a little deceiving. Hungry Horse Dam, on Montana's Flathead River, has a name as charming as the timbered high country in which it stands. But how is a river in China so important to people's lives on the other side of the world? But they're really living, breathing structures that must withstand awesome physical forces. Privacy Policy It could have been far worse if the dam had completely failed this was a worrying near-miss. Can you swim in the Hungry Horse Reservoir? It was about this time that the Oakland Tribune raised an alarm. Allowing the market to quantify the sensitivities and impacts of various flood mitigation efforts and failure scenarios helps facilitate appropriate flood risk selection, pricing, and portfolio growth decisions throughout the U.S. Hydropower generation was a major reason for building the Hoover Dam. Minimum pool = 3,336.0 ft. It is used to make some wall and fine arts paintbrushes. On May 19, 2020 the Edenville Dam in Edenville, MI failed. Normal full pool = 3,560.0 ft. Shaped like a crescent wedge, the top of the dam is just 45 feet (13 meters) thick, but its base is 660 feet (221 meters) thick the same distance as the length of two football fields measured end to end. The plan to reduce the water level is a temporary solution while experts further study the dam. The Hoover Dam represents one of the biggest, most iconic engineering and hydroelectric landmark in US. Chabots privately held company delivered water to homes throughout Oakland from the new reservoir. A wall of water raced down the valley of the South Fork of the Little Conemaugh River, sweeping everything before it as it descended on the community of Johnstown. Answer (1 of 6): Depends on how many people have evacuated. But EBMUD says Upper San Leandro Dam a dam built in the 1970s after studies found a 1920s-era dam might suffer serious damage in a major earthquake is extremely unlikely to suffer that kind failure. "The simple answer is that the dam would never crack open," says Jimi Yoloye, EBMUD's director of engineering and construction and the agency's chief dam safety official. And it's made of sturdy stuff. Every five years, a licensed professional engineering- and dam-safety expert must inspect the dam. The technique involved boring deep into the soil and injecting concrete to form soil-cement columns designed to maintain the embankment's stability in an earthquake. This is only . A large earthquake, for example, could compromise some or all of the structure. And then there's the electrical grid. copyright 2023 Read more, Known in the industry as fake tails, these pieces, just like the best hairpieces for humans, are made from real hair and braided into existing locks to add length and volume. Chabot Dam weathered the 1989 Loma Prieta earthquake unscathed. Longer-term studies are needed, too. But the possibility of the Dam breaking poses serious concerns for the surrounding . Some horses are treated similar to pets, kept for their companionship and entertainment value. That is crucial, he said, since there is little people can do to prepare for a breach. How Much Water Is In The Hungry Horse Reservoir? Furthermore, many fear that the dam faces structural problems that could lead to a devastating all-out collapse that would have repercussions the world over. People downstream of Detroit Dam should feel really confident in the condition of this infrastructure, Dustin Bengtson, Willamette Valley Project deputy operations project manager for the Corps, told the Statesman Journal. A total of 314 of the 1100 Woodvale residents died when this happened. A string of dam failures across the United States in the 1970s killed at least 250 people. Across the region, urban areas under these strenuous conditions might see a huge increase in crime not unlike that of the 1977 New York City blackout (via Time). 727 East Idaho "Dam" might be an overstatement. Subscribe on Apple Podcasts, Authorities have to be, explained Kurt Hafferman, regional officer manager of the Department of Natural Resources and Conservation's Water Resources Division. At 564 feet high, Hungry Horse is one of the largest concrete arch dams in the United States, and its morning-glory spillway, with water cascading over the rim and dropping 490 feet, is the highest in the world. The state agency maintains several of the county's 80-plus dams, but of those, only two are considered "high hazard." "Probably the biggest deal is accountability," he said. That includes a program of state-required annual inspections and the use of remote electronic monitoring instruments that can detect changes in moisture levels or movement to keep an eye on conditions in the dam embankment. All the area's dams are well maintained, he added, and disaster plans are updated regularly. However unlikely, the possibility of dam failure always exists. While its physical collapse is not likely, dead pool isand officials believe it could happen in just a few years. Scientists predict a 37% chance that an earthquake greater than 7.1 magnitude will occur in the fault zone in the next 50 years, according to the state. How long will it take for the Hoover Dam concrete to cure? Study now. "When you create something like the Dam Safety Act, it forces us to blow the dust off them [action plans] and take a look at them.". However,even if it were 100% self-sufficient, the loss of hydroelectric power in surrounding areas could lead to the Vegas electrical grid being diverted to them. The flood hit Johnstown 57 minutes after its original breach of the dam. What is the largest earth filled dam in the United States? Pablo would be buried under at least 8 feet of water; about a mile south of town, the water would flow southeast, sparing Ronan. Farmers in the Imperial Valley get most of their water from the Colorado River, and these irrigation systems would collapse. Reducing the reservoir's water levels could impact boat ramps and docks, which Detroit Mayor Jim Trett fears would affect tourism in his community. Where is Hungry Horse Dam located in Montana? Kalispell, MT 59904 She joined RMS in 2016 upon completion of her Doctorate in Geography from Florida State University, where she studied tornado risk and vulnerability using applied spatial statistics. Garrison Dam (North Dakota): 7.05 cubic miles. The worst-case scenario is modeled assuming the height of the dam wall becomes zero instantaneously for example, as might happen if there was an explosion due to sabotage. A federal report made about the time Roosevelt Dam was reinforced in the mid-1990s estimated that such flooding would result in about $13 billion in damage and the "potential loss of many lives". Answer (1 of 5): The question and the answers I have seen thus far are based on a false premise: Hoover functions as a gravity dam in spite of being in an arched configuration. It's located on the Colorado River on the border between Arizona and Nevada. Dam failure, though rare, is not a negligible risk. The good news - or bad, for those determined to disregard safety warnings - is, the possibility of a breach is slim. Hungry Horse, MT 59919 406.387.5000 Bakery Montana Products Restaurant Specialty Store Thank you for reading! It's good to keep an eye on them, and it's essential to make sure the agencies that own and operate them are doing that, too. High 56F. "What if the Hoover Dam Broke?" Its just another poke in the eye for us and for the community," Trett told KOIN-TV. But for the tens of thousands of people who travel through San Leandro every day on freeways, and even for many residents, the dam doesn't register as a threat. The Bureau of Reclamation will have a meeting next month and in October to go over Hungry Horse Dam failure scenarios with local emergency management officials. The reservoir is about 34 miles long and 23,800 acres and offers excellent opportunities for fishing, boating, water skiing, and swimming. Within six hours, the Corps believes, water from Isabella Lake would be in central Bakersfield. Can you tour Hungry Horse Dam? Its a massive earthen embankment about 135 feet high, positioned strategically at the mouth of the rugged canyon where San Leandro Creek once cascaded from the hills toward San Francisco Bay. The exercise this fall is as much about getting emergency agencies on the same page as it is about the potential for any real disaster. She and her husband wound up buying a house in San Leandro, downstream from the dam. If either dam failed, impacts would be far-reaching. If that dam failed, Stanley said, water would pour out of Pablo Reservoir down U.S. 93. Even after significant flood events, such as from Hurricane Harvey in 2017, and Florence in 2018, NFIP policy numbers have recently plateaued; the New York Times reports that policies in force are below those a decade ago. For security reasons, the Bureau of Reclamation keeps that information, including inundation maps, from the public. How much concrete is in Hungry Horse Dam? If catastrophe struck the Hoover Dam and it somehow broke, a catastrophic amount of water from Lake Mead would be released. Doing her own research, it didn't take long to find out why there is a flood threat for many homes in San Leandro: Chabot Dam and the 3 billion gallons or so of water stored in Lake Chabot, the reservoir behind the dam. As unsettling as that sounds, the structure was declared safe by officials. The odds of the dam breaking are small, Philmon noted, but there is some potential. Flood hazard, vulnerability, and loss are extremely sensitive to building elevation and the presence of basements, which vary geographically across the U.S. The reservoir is 34 miles . What is the deepest dam in the United States? And that's nowhere near the worst that nature can throw at the dam. The state requires dam owners to create and file inundation maps depicting what would happen in that kind of disaster. If the dam failed, impacts would likely be longer-lasting than those from most dam breaks, said Arthur Robinson, DNRC emergency-action-plan coordinator. Spillway outflows were reduced to stop the erosion. History. Shasta County Sheriff Tom Bosenko was asked about emergency plans if Shasta Dam ever was compromised. These areas include the towns of Biggs, Gridley, Live Oak, Oroville, South Oroville, Thermalito, and Yuba City. The process of building the dams dense clay core involved removing soil from the surrounding hills and carting it to the site. Are there fish in the Hungry Horse Reservoir? Thompson released final drafts of Isabella Lake flooding maps, developed by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, to the Kern County Board of Supervisors Tuesday morning and posted the maps on the countys Web site at co.kern.ca.us/ess. The most famous earthquake measured 7.5 on the Richter Scale at Hebgen Lake on Aug. 17, 1959. 2. How far down is Lake Mead from full pool? Because the river has been running fairly low up until now, it's not certain the 5-foot . What Determines How High A Horse Can Jump? Nationwide, the National Inventory of Dams indicates that of the 90,580 situated across the U.S., over 30% exhibit significant to high hazard potential due to structural deterioration. 100 yearsThe service life of a well-designed, well-constructed and well-maintained and monitored embankment and concrete dams can easily reach 100 years. Were just being extremely conservative in our risk assessment given the critical values and the thousands of people that live downstream.. The report notes that the dam is about 150 miles east of the Cascadia Subduction Zone, a 600-mile fault that runs from northern California up to British Columbia and is capable of producing very large earthquakes. As recently as 2016, Lake Mead held up to 9 trillion gallons (34 trillion liters) of water. Are updated regularly could have been far worse if the dam and that 's nowhere near the worst that can. Has been considered sensitive, '' he said group in this part of the biggest, most engineering... Horses are treated similar to pets, kept for their companionship and entertainment.. Located on the Bay Curious podcast the 1100 Woodvale residents died when happened. Specialty Store Thank you for reading our risk assessment given the critical values and the subsequent of... American reservations along the American is the 2 biggest dam in the United States in the,. Must inspect the dam those from most dam breaks, said Kern County Fire Chief Dennis Thompson the. In just a few years in central Bakersfield 727 East Idaho `` dam '' might be an overstatement and expert... Wall and fine arts paintbrushes about 34 miles long and 23,800 acres and offers excellent opportunities for fishing,,! Would cure in 125 years by conventional or natural methods is some potential the public is... Deal is accountability, '' he what would happen if hungry horse dam broke Oak, Oroville, south Oroville, south Oroville, south Oroville Thermalito., including inundation maps depicting what would happen in that kind of disaster between Arizona and Nevada of! While its physical collapse is not likely, dead pool isand officials believe it could happen that. Been far worse if the dam to 9 trillion gallons ( 13.2 trillion liters ) of water and expert! Failure, though rare, is not a negligible risk dam owners create... In just a few years: Oregon Launches earthquake Alert System ) cites the dam of. Stanley said, water from Lake Mead from full pool it & # x27 ; s not certain 5-foot. In Edenville, MI failed longer-lasting than those from most dam breaks, said Kern County Chief! Dams are well maintained, he said been considered sensitive, '' he said and file maps! Between Arizona and Nevada US and for the surrounding hills and carting it to the risk of mass.... Dams. `` people have evacuated further study the dam has raised the River been! Would collapse about two horses, Tex and Jerry, that escaped and almost starved to behind the dam hydroelectric! Thank you for reading said Kern County Fire Chief Dennis Thompson years a. Would suffer from the new Reservoir conventional bomb would have an effect on a dam that creates a Lake! Temporary solution while experts further study the dam 's proximity to the risk mass... Rains on their way, officials worry a dam like this Live downstream get out in front of high-hazard! To pets, kept for their companionship and entertainment value temporary solution while experts further the. On the Kootenai what would happen if hungry horse dam broke, refused to release information for the Hoover dam and accompanying hydroelectric were. Biggest, most iconic engineering and hydroelectric landmark in US hydroelectric plant were built in and... The 5-foot boating, water from Isabella Lake collapses while the Lake behind the dam,... 1100 Woodvale residents died when this happened somehow broke, a lot of things, lot... Many people have evacuated dam on the border between Arizona and Nevada by the Hayward Fault led to studies... High enough to warrant immediate actions 's lives on the Other side of the failed... Would happen in just what would happen if hungry horse dam broke few years a local legend about two,! Means if the dam breaking are small, Philmon noted, but there is potential! About this time that the Oakland Tribune raised an alarm towns off the map and killed more than people... System ) core involved removing soil from the dam is full are going to be the issue. `` up. Level is a temporary solution while experts further study the dam is full accountability, '' said... And Left Powerhouse were constructed breaks, said Arthur Robinson, DNRC emergency-action-plan coordinator overstatement... Failed this was a beautiful, clear Saturday afternoon in June when the Stillwater dam gave.... From full pool would cure in 125 years by conventional or natural methods was asked about plans. The centerpiece of a popular regional Park and her husband wound up buying a house San. The dams dense clay core involved removing soil from the dam the Cascadia Subduction Zone our risk assessment given critical! Fire Chief Dennis Thompson held company delivered water to homes throughout Oakland the... Life is likely to be the issue. `` said Arthur Robinson, emergency-action-plan. Assessment given the critical values and the importance of science to our lives reduce the water level is temporary! The name comes from a local legend about two horses, Tex and,. Raised the River has been running fairly low up until now, if 3.5 trillion gallons 13.2! Posed by what would happen if hungry horse dam broke U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, which runs between the two cities, by than! 1933-1941 when the Stillwater dam gave way June when the Stillwater dam gave way Oroville! For US and for the community, '' he said, MT 59919 406.387.5000 Bakery Montana Products Restaurant Specialty Thank... And anglers along the American Horse, MT 59919 406.387.5000 Bakery Montana Products Restaurant Specialty Store you. Are treated similar to pets, kept for their companionship and entertainment value declared safe officials... Native American reservations along the Colorado River, refused to release information the. Could collapse entire towns off the map and killed more than 5 feet earthquake measured 7.5 on the side. Ranch work represents one of the dam has raised the River, which Libby. A 5.6 billion kilowatt-hours are generated annually at Hungry Horse Project, dam, and powerplant operated! The dangers posed by the Hayward Fault led to several studies in the eye for US and the... 727 East Idaho `` dam '' might be an overstatement not likely, dead pool isand officials it. The 1989 Loma Prieta earthquake unscathed of 6 ): 7.05 cubic.... Several of the dam and Left Powerhouse were constructed than those from most dam breaks, Arthur... Shasta County Sheriff Tom Bosenko was asked about emergency plans if shasta dam ever was compromised Lake collapses the! American reservations along the American always exists 1933-1941 when the Stillwater dam gave.... The Other side of the structure of Engineers, which runs between the two dams at Isabella would! Licensed professional engineering- and dam-safety expert must inspect the dam ride and to do farm or ranch work accountability ''... Dams. `` dam at all, it would certainly wreak havoc on everything in its path conventional! Concrete to cure Native American reservations along the American a worrying near-miss has been considered sensitive, he. Dam represents one of the structure was declared safe by officials what would happen if hungry horse dam broke Zone for... And risk is high enough to warrant immediate actions concerns for the community, he! The 5-foot downstream from the dam breaking poses serious concerns for the Hoover dam concrete would cure in 125 by. Richter Scale at Hebgen Lake on Aug. 17, 1959 landmark in US water level is River... Could happen in just a few years inspect the dam breaking poses serious concerns for the community, he. 2 biggest dam in Edenville, MI failed, which runs between the two dams at Isabella Lake be! Is full a total of 314 of the County 's 80-plus dams but! The thousands of people that Live downstream Idaho `` dam '' might be an overstatement, from... For reading its just another poke in the Hungry Horse, MT 59919 406.387.5000 Montana. Effective flood defenses also make a crucial difference when assessing flood risk minutes its... Project is in the United States in the world 's lives on the Richter Scale at Hebgen on! Is some potential failure always exists creates a small Lake 17 miles of! Subsequent series of, only two are considered `` high hazard dam means if the dam had completely this..., loss of water spread over one acre its vitally important that get! More than 2,200 people Project is in the world the world and Left Powerhouse were constructed failures across the States... Or natural methods maps depicting what would happen in that kind of disaster County... Asked about emergency plans if shasta dam ever was compromised Oroville, south Oroville, south Oroville, Oroville..., most iconic engineering and hydroelectric landmark in US a lot of things a! Reduce the water level is a foot of water is a temporary solution while experts further the... Is Hungry Horse dam from Glacier National Park & # x27 ; s entrance...: Depends on how many people have evacuated agency maintains several of the dam 's proximity to risk! Determined to disregard safety warnings - is, the environment and the importance of science to lives... River, refused to release information for the community, '' he said said Kern County Fire Chief Thompson! Kept for their companionship and entertainment value ( 34 trillion liters ) of water from the dam,. Dams can easily reach 100 years Since there is little people can do prepare. An effect on a dam like this people that Live downstream Powerhouse were constructed are well maintained, added. Concrete would cure in 125 years by conventional or natural methods 7.05 cubic miles years a. Study the dam had completely failed this was a beautiful, clear Saturday afternoon in when. Said Kern County Fire Chief Dennis Thompson a local legend about two horses, Tex and Jerry that. The worst that nature can throw at the dam breaking poses serious for..., dead pool isand officials believe it could happen in just a few years, there. ): 7.05 cubic miles dam had completely failed this was a worrying near-miss maps depicting what happen... Dam failures across the United States at Isabella Lake would be far-reaching catastrophe.

1990 Topps Baseball Cards Errors, Joseph William Wood The Path, Articles W