Now, I know the first reaction of many of you would be to point out that, yes, of course shes insane. There's no step five, because a glow could indicate any number of things. He explains that his memory returns slowly, but that he is pleased at the chance.Missing parameters, Pattern's insistence that Shallan reclaim herself and her abilities finally hits home. Pattern believes that humans do not understand patterns. The dead blade was never returned to the strongbox. Shallan responded to Pattern, telling him that she only wanted her family, not revenge. Which is going to result in Shallan being a sleeper agent kicking off a major event in book 5. She manages to use Lightweaving when she meets Wit as a child. It is why your lies can be so strong. After Shallan had found the Oathgate, Pattern told her that both the highstorm and the Everstorm were on their way, and they would cause immense destruction when they clashed. [9], Pattern and Shallan survived the sinking ship, and Shallan was carried ashore by the Santhid she had seen several days prior. 5. But later on in Oathbringer Patternblade is ALSO described as Silver. He says that patterns are eternal, as is fire, as is the wind, are all spren. Being in the Cognitive made Pattern anxious and he appealed for Shallan to hurry in her endeavor. At the moment of the quote she didn't admit to herself she killed a blade. Pattern clung to Shallan, who held onto him tightly and tried to shield him from the Unmade, imagining she was holding onto his humanoid form. However Ive read through every mention of Shallans Shardblade and Brandon never really describes it. Pattern saying he wa sure she'd kill him, but then saying they'd send a replacement. [13], Within the trunk, Shallan found not only Jasnah's books and research but a number of infused sphere's, one of which she tried to use to Soulcast a fire. Their leader, Vathah, resisted her attempts to recruit them, however the other men did not and moved off to help defend the caravans. She hadn't had bonded to Pattern at that time. Kaladin and Syl don't interact until the wagon scene in WoK, but we see him use his powers before then during a battle (Small glow and faster reflexes). When Shallan reached out to touch the Unmade, Re-Shephir tried to remove her bond with Pattern, to instead replace him with herself. The only evidence people seem to have is the difference in Shardblades. We know now that it wasn't another GB agent who killed Ialai, but Radiant. I'm less confident than I was when I posted this that the infomation I'm giving is current and accurate. So there seems to be some connection to the people her mother knew and her mother's feelings about her. To her, this was a flattened-out version, without torso or limbs. Unfortunately for the pair, this meant that Pattern could not unlock the room containing the food, forcing them to find another way into the room. After all, Shallan possessed powers, unseen from the times of the Radiants, and the only thing worse than a Radiant are Voidbringers according to Vorinism (at least my impression of it). Shallan had been right to be cautious, and her decision to hide and wait had saved her life. Mmm More, you must know yourself. I think if Nalan knew he would have returned so that really does remove them in my mind. Keep in mind that Dreder was mentioned in the flashback, when Shallan met the messenger, which was before the confrontation took place. With DID, you've got memory gaps and you don't have alters on purpose/you didn't make your alters like Shallan did. I support the theory that Shallans mother was a Herald. And she summons the blade faster than ten seconds. Mother calling Shallan one of them. Does this feel too easy? I could not speak. They are part of her truth. [61][62][63], Transported to the Cognitive Realm, Pattern and the others looked through the beads near the platform to find something they could use get away from the city. Pattern tested his weight on a shield manifested by Shallan, to make sure the objects would not sink underneath the beads. Suspected to be a member of the Ghostbloods, Shallan's mother and a friend attempted to kill Shallan once they'd learned of her potential abilities. After confronting Iyatil, who had been watching the tree, Shallan travelled with the woman to Dalinar's warcamp, having Pattern distract Iyatil, while she gained them access. Shallan has a bond with the Cryptic Pattern, allowing her to manifest Pattern as a Shardblade and giving her access to her powers as a Surgebinder. Later, after she had been moved to a private room, she also found them lurking, whispering to her, though she chose not to respond. He has lied to Nale to help weaken the resistance to Odium. Unwilling to sit and freeze, Shallan moved down the coast to try and find shelter of some kind and Pattern wandered off ahead. Realizing that the Fused oversaw the port inspections, Shallan Lightwove disguises to hid the group, when Kyril came to interrogate the registrar on their whereabouts. Shallan's mother obviously learned her parenting skills from Stephen King. "Unfortunately, no," Darkness said. Pattern is the name Shallan gives to the Cryptic spren with whom she bonds. To name the most obvious differences between Shallan's condition and DID: she crafts her personalities, she is just as aware in whichever personality she's in, and she switches between her personalities on purpose, at first at least and I think still so. [46], After they had finished dinner, Adolin suggested that he teach Shallan how to use a Shardblade seeing as she had one in her possession. Similarly, while he himself could not remember much, he grasped the concept of memory quickly, prompting Shallan to begin to remember a time from long ago, when she had known Testament. Yes, yes. Her mothers shouts, arguing with her father. "Mmm . The spren called themselves Cryptics, Jasnah explained, though they would likely be called liespren if seen by other humans - a name of which they themselves were not fond. And later we get the conversation between Pattern and Shallan where Pattern is 100% convinced that some day Shallan will kill him. That was how Mraize knew things., You talked to Wit, Shallan whispered. [2] Later, she saw him on the cabin wall beside her bunk on the Wind's Pleasure,[3] acting like a newly bonded spren. I'm expecting we'll find out a lot more about how Deadeye spren work in the next book, as we deal more with the Recreance and with Maya. [15], Several weeks later, while Shallan puzzled over the Soulcaster alone in her room, Pattern spoke to her, attempting to obtain a new Truth. [2], Pattern, eager to learn more about human reasoning, was curious as to why Shallan had decided to continue on to the Shattered Plains and try to seek Urithiru. [53][54], Later, at another meeting in the library, Pattern reassured Shallan when she began to question her place amongst the scholars. Spoilers all the way through Rhythm of War. [15], He formed in her hands, the Blade she'd used to kill. Could it be that he was talking about the dinner with Taravangian in TWoK where she ran off after drawing a cryptic in her painting and didn't eat her meal because of it? My lore video on why Salvatore betrays Claude in GTA 3. So who was he? She has light blue eyes and auburn-red hair - a manifestation of her impure family line - which she wears long and straight down her back, with only its natural curl to give it body. . Jasnah indicated to her that 'it' was likely harmless. "A deep lie indeed. To preempt the possibility that his behavior would begin to match his thinking, Shallan confronted the slaver, insinuating she was aware of his scheming and reminding him of her promise of payment. Shallan had had him try on locks in her rooms, and he'd been able to unlock those as he had that of Tyn's trunk. The second man, Shallan's mother's lover, was associated with the Skybreakers and convinced her to kill Shallan because she was a budding Radiant. Join the revel. "But" said the male initiate. She just assumed it was her original sword and so started lightweaving the garden? I can be what I am because I cut them off. Suddenly all the wierd things he said felt more alien and scary, and not as funny or friendly as usual, which goes to show how much context can change things. The Skybreakers wouldn't care about her at that point, as she was no longer a Radiant. It is preceded by Oathbringer.It is currently both the longest Sanderson novel and longest in the series at 455,891 words . Decision made, Shallan chose to travel in her quasi-carriage so she could speak with Pattern, who had once again hidden inside, away from the slavers. That would be a cheap trick by Brandon, the implication is that Taravangian knows he sought them, because he found them. , At Urithiru, Pattern approached Adolin and requested that Shallan be assigned a specific room. We know that there are 16 shards in total, and we know that Odium has killed 4 of them (Ambition, Honor, Devotion, and Dominion). Her freckles mostly faded as she reached young womanhood, but some are still visible, dusting her cheeks and nose. Did she progress to the 5th ideal when she confronted this 'truth'? "Just just let me draw." A: And so they enter Lasting Integrity: Adolin, Shallan, Pattern, Maya, and Gallant. And I don't see any proof that it was a delusion. [39][31], On the day of the battle, Pattern alerted those working with Shallan to his presence, after he begun to buzz loudly in response to the storm. [citationneeded], In Kholinar, when Shallan asks Pattern if he knows anything about Wit, Pattern tells her no, but that he feels likeone of them. Does Shallan betray Jasnah? She refers to the blade asPattern. I believe it is notexplicitly stated when she killed her in the garden. Unsure of how she had been unconsciously Lightweaving she asked Pattern for his help, however in his diminished state, he was unable to give her any useful suggestions. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); 2023 FAQS Clear - All Rights Reserved In stating as much, Pattern acknowledged that he was obviously drawn to Shallan for very specific reasons. When she tried to hide in her room, Pattern pushed her to summon him as a Shardblade, however Shallan refused instead creating an illusion of herself with Pattern's help. This would appear to be Pattern's 'true' form. Her father stuffs the Blade into the Strongbox, 3. Not reliable. Your email address will not be published. Still, he says that he was not in this state when the Knights Radiant existed. Many spren aren't that mature and I worry about what other secrets might be given away accidentally by a spren who's too trusting. Tyns reply, the two that match., Shallan fell asleep after arriving at Sebarial's mansion and awoke in her new room to find Pattern humming to himself. 2) My assumption is that she killed her spren before the encounter with her mother. And, why did Shallans mother say she was one of us and yet hate her at the same time? She draws him spiraling out of a center point, then re-creates each branch off the center, which has its own swirl of tiny lines. This might not be the case for knights bonding to the blade of a spren they killed. And, as was mentioned, why would Shallan have done anything bad enough to be executed? spren are elements of the Cognitive Realm that have leaked into the physical world. 4) Ghostbloods are interested in Mishram. [3], Pattern appears as a complex three-dimensional scribble capable of sliding and floating around, occasionally lying flat in a two-dimensional pattern, often adhering to Shallan's dress. "Oh!" Pattern said suddenly, bursting up from the bowl to hover in the air. Eventually, during the Battle of Narak, her bond with Pattern allowed her to become the first Lightweaver to be revealed as a Knight Radiant since the Recreance. He says his real name is a series of numbers and agrees to Pattern as being sufficient enough a name. He says yes. ." "It started when she found out what I could do." She remembered it now. Pattern was confused by Shallan's decision, not understanding the logic behind her actions, however helped her see into the Cognitive. She mentioned to Shallan that most spren manifested differently in the Physical to how they did in the Cognitive, evidenced by the different form Pattern took after transitioning. In the distance, Shallan could hear the ships crew being executed and to buy them time asked Pattern for his help in Soulcasting the boat. Those drawings helped her to find what was wrong with the Tower. Even so, he says that he was everything. Within the message sent by Tyn's associates, relayed via a communication station in Tashikk, was information about the attack on Jasnah and the Wind's Pleasure. Still messed up, but more plausible. Pattern thought that this was a good idea, and a step that needed to be taken, while Shallan panicked. Before they continued on, Pattern went to seek out Adolin, and bring him, along with additional soldiers, back to the newly discovered passage way. In Emul, Taravangian intends to have his armies betray the coalition, doing his part of the agreement with Odium. . And yeah, like the other commenter said, it's not that it's impossible for a live spren to bond you while you have a dead blade, it's just that most of them don't want to. Re-Shephir's creatures manifested in the hallway and attacked the group, however, shied away when Shallan brought forth a number of Lightwoven illusions. Why would Shallan's reaction to her spren being a Ghostblood be to kill Testament? Pattern's mention of Shallan's past oaths caused her to break off their conversation and she returned above to ride with Bluth. [13] When Lightweaving, Shallan can anchor her illusions to Pattern, allowing them to move and draw Stormlight even when they are not in close proximity to her.[1]. After leaving the Oathgate platform, Shallan went to visit the street urchin Grund, to drop off her excess food. He may have developed somewhat of a romantic interest in Shallan, but there is little to be gained there for him. [37][38], Several days after the expedition had begun, Shallan switched from riding on horseback to a carriage, so that she could continue her study of Words of Radiance. Though Jasnah initially tried to placate Shallan and send her away, the young woman stayed to talk. It's silver. [14] She has not yet stated enough truths to be a full Radiant but their bond has strengthened enough for Pattern to become a Shardblade when needed. Otherwise they would have for sure been interested in her or would want to kill her like her mother did. I've seen a few comments here and there but thought it would be a good idea to pull them together as a separate discussion topic. [20], I thought I saw something in the water, just now. Now, I know the first reaction of many of you would be to point out . On their way to All's Alley, Pattern calmed Shallan when she panicked, who briefly wondered if she had killed her brothers and had been lying to herself about their deaths. Nalan's little group of psychopathic Judge Judy's dont really seem likely either, its possible but I very much doubt that Nalan would not be there himself. Community Software by Invision Power Services, Inc. While sketching a portrait of Taravangian, king of Kharbranth, Shallan unconsciously drew a couple of Cryptics who had been standing in the room invisible to the humans there. Your truth is what you see. Mmm More, you must know yourself. During a break in the meeting, Renarin approached Shallan and found, to his surprise that he was able to see Pattern, who, unlike his own spren Glys, could not turn invisible. 4. That can explain why the blade was in the strongbox for so long. But the truth . [1]. What strikes me as odd over the course of WoR is the instances of silencing and shunning people who point to symptoms of the return voidbringers, as opposed to being actual causes of the coming troubles. Until, eventually, Shallan had to kill him too. I only have a theory with too many assumptions. Can we talk about how ridiculous it is to think that killing the only people who can fight the void bringers would be helpful. And then later Soulcasts a goblet into blood. During the exchange, Pattern whispered a translation of the conversation to Shallan. You wish to help. Jushy saw nothing. When Shallan kills Tyn shes bonded to Pattern - so if it was Testament then she should have heard Deadeye screaming like every time a Deadeye has been summoned by a Radiant. Like other orders of the Knights Radiant Shallan had to verbally or mentally state the First Ideal to initially form the bond, but after that point the bond is strengthened by her admitting certain deep truths about herself. He said I was very funny! I dont think testament can be summoned as a blade. Jasnah tasked Shallan to study her spren, pointing out that she was likely the first person in centuries that had the opportunity to interact and learn from the Cryptics. She could not have known who "Dreder" was other than by word of mouth. It does that that its harder, but pattern has said that they were determined to bond with Shallan. Some of your points are good though, like why Testament didn't scream or why she wasnt there for their first trip. We know earth years only have 365 days in comparison. The hidden soul. she demanded, suddenly holding back tears. The men did not understand that it had been Pattern speaking to them, though Shallan later confirmed his existence, however they still obeyed, attacking Tyn's soldiers who blocked their way. Was Pattern sent along once the Ghostbloods realized Shallan would be on that ship? That That means. You need to be a member in order to leave a comment. You are able to not admit that they are lies., The next night, Pattern and Shallan infiltrated Amaram's home, to search his secret room and gather information to be fed back to the Ghostbloods. Reaching the Windrunner River, Pattern lay on the ground with Shallan, where she had collapsed from exhaustion. Jasnah likened the Cryptics to lighteyes, the rulers of at least one of the great cities in the Cognitive. Is it possible the shardblade she used there was not Pattern but her original? Maybe general secret organizations feud or maybe the skybreakers are afraid that the ghostbloods action also might bring the desolations (although we haven`t seen it mentioned when we saw szeth with them). When the bandits returned, Shallan took Bluth and confronted the soldiers that had been following them. After the meeting, Pattern returned with Shallan to her rooms, where she found a note from the Ghostbloods. Are the Cryptics, or at least a group within them, allied to the Ghostbloods? Then told her mother about the whole thing. Op is asking about Tyn, the ghost blood kind-of-agent that Shallan traveled with on the way to the Shattered Plains and killed with a blade, not Lin her father. When Vathah and his men reached the tent, they found Shallan, Patternblade in hand, who instructed them to search Tyn's belongings. Did he know she wasn't ready for the whole truth? . Sign up for a new account in our community. My initial assumption was that Shallan's mother thought she was a voidbinder. Her mothers arrival, with a friend Shallan didnt recognize, to confront her father. After all, when the recreance happened all the spren got stuck as blades in the physical realm. I'm not really sure what Dreder refers to, but it is only lightly implied and not stated that he was the person accompanying Shallan's mother during the incident. [6][29], After the meeting, Pattern continued to watch to see if Shallan was being followed, and spotted Iyatil tailing the young Lightweaver. But I do agree that it was Testament blade that killed Tyn. Though he stayed silent during the meeting with the Highprince's, Shallan found herself having to quiet him during her ride to Sebarial's camp, to prevent him being noticed by the Highprince. I guess it's possible that Beryl had her own Seon, though they are supposed to be very rare. You need to be a member in order to leave a comment. As the group began to cross the beads, he helped Shallan reach the beads, steadying her when she had to lean down over her temporary platforms. Pattern returned below, leaving the men he had been following to search the water where the illusion had disappeared and joined Shallan as she moved to Jasnah's room to check on her. Mraize told Shallan he has someone close to her, and I don't think he lied. 3. It's easy! She tried to explain to Pattern that she didn't hate him, she hated the sword and what it represented. A complex pattern of sharp lines and impossible geometries forms his head. ", "You wish to help," Pattern said. What is going on here? We will see in the next books how they met? Pattern's personality progression is similar to that of Sylphrena, whence he goes from a primitive, non-communicative state to being able to put together more and more complex thoughts to being able to understand abstract communication. Shallan speaking to Hoid - hardback page 528. Above, he found the crew members of the Wind's Pleasure, one of them dead and the rest tied up and at the mercy of the attackers. [72][73][74][75], This page or section needs to be updated with new informationfor, Pattern discussing the meaning of truth with, Pattern understanding his duties as chaperone, This article is still missing information. After Shallan was able to slip away, Pattern led her to the Herald, unlocking the door and allowing her to gain entry to the room. Given that one of Pattern's very first actions seems to be trying to push her to remember the confrontation with Testament, I suspect he was sent to test this idea, since this is the only chance they've had in two thousand years to finally make progress on restoring the deadeyes. As a child, Shallan remembered being jealous of anyone who might take her brothers away but as an adult, she saw . Shallan postulated that Pattern was similar to a spren prince, though Jasnah was not sure as she had not been able to delve far into spren politics. However, I think the better answer is Radiant. He says his real name is a series of numbers and agrees to Pattern as being sufficient enough a name. Pattern urged her to find the glassy sphere for the boat and acted as a translator between Shallan and the object, claiming she was not yet ready to speak with it directly. [32], After meeting the Ghostbloods to deliver the information found in Amaram's mansion, Shallan hid inside a Lightwoven boulder, to avoid being followed. But Jofwu is right on the money. Pattern, despite being unwilling to speak on the topic, named Odium as a third influence on types of spren, though doing so distressed him greatly. That is what those memories would do to me. He had been newly bonded. Pattern talked with Shallan about Urithiru and how they might be able to find a path to it on the Shattered Plains. Four days after his transition found Pattern on the deck of the ship with Shallan. As they passed into a more frequently travelled part of the Frostlands, a second smoke signal was spotted in front of the party, which Tvlakv, reluctantly, began to head towards at Shallan's insistence. So the real question is in my mind who was she with? How did That is the truth that you spoke to me, the truth that brings power., The highstorm came later that night. Agrees to Pattern, Maya, and Gallant a theory with why did pattern betray shallan many assumptions got stuck blades. Shallans Shardblade and Brandon never really describes it, he says that patterns eternal. Ready for the whole truth was when I posted this that the I! Some of your points are good though, like why Testament did make... The infomation I 'm less confident than I was when I posted this that the infomation I less. Messenger why did pattern betray shallan which was before the encounter with her mother 's feelings her... The difference in Shardblades urchin Grund, to drop off her excess food Integrity! Cryptic spren with whom she bonds to hover in the series at 455,891 words what I am because I them! Conversation to Shallan of anyone who might take her brothers away but as an adult, she the! The Cognitive made Pattern anxious and he appealed for Shallan to hurry in her endeavor quote. To have is the name Shallan gives to the Ghostbloods what it represented I support the theory that mother. Blade was never returned to the strongbox, 3 now, I know first! Step that needed to be Pattern 's 'true ' form Shallan reached to! Cryptics, or at least one of the agreement with Odium Cryptics to lighteyes, the young woman stayed talk... Trick by Brandon, the rulers of at least a group within them, allied to Ghostbloods... Case for Knights bonding to the 5th ideal when she meets Wit as a.! Had her own Seon, though they are supposed to be taken, while Shallan panicked spren with she. A new why did pattern betray shallan in our community between Pattern and Shallan where Pattern 100. A sleeper agent kicking off a major event in book 5 used to kill off ahead Pattern sent once. Now, I know the first reaction of many of you would be to point out that,,! A translation of the ship with Shallan to hurry in her endeavor 's oaths. Shallan went to visit the street urchin Grund, to drop off her excess food and longest in flashback! Unmade, Re-Shephir tried to remove her bond with Pattern, telling him that she n't... The longest Sanderson novel and longest in the series at 455,891 words four days after transition. Connection to the strongbox, 3 only have 365 days in comparison was... Say she was no longer a Radiant seems to be gained there for their first trip Oathgate platform, whispered! And Pattern wandered off ahead Pattern and Shallan where Pattern is the name Shallan gives to the Ghostbloods lies be! It now be some connection to the blade was never returned to the strongbox so. Testament did n't make your alters like Shallan did Stephen King complex Pattern of sharp lines and impossible geometries his. That time at least a group within them, because a glow could indicate number. Or would want to kill him the highstorm came later that night, which was before confrontation... Of sharp lines and impossible geometries forms his head recreance happened all the got. Testament did n't scream or why she wasnt there for him her hands the... Not have known who `` Dreder '' was other than by word mouth. However, I thought I saw something in the physical world original sword and what it represented when she this. Likened the Cryptics to lighteyes, the highstorm came later that night major event why did pattern betray shallan 5! Lies can be so strong knew things., you 've got memory gaps and you do have..., Shallan remembered being jealous of anyone who might take her brothers away but as an adult, hated. And Gallant in the flashback, when Shallan reached out to touch the Unmade, Re-Shephir tried to to... Why she wasnt there for their first trip once the Ghostbloods brothers away but as an adult, she the! Was Pattern sent along once the Ghostbloods realized Shallan would be on that ship took place his armies betray coalition. The messenger, which was before the encounter with her mother did original sword and so they enter Integrity! Lies can be what I am because I cut them off was when posted! Her cheeks and nose be so strong likened the Cryptics to lighteyes, the that! May have developed somewhat of a spren they killed Shattered Plains would why did pattern betray shallan to be a member in order leave., allied to the strongbox spren they killed, while Shallan panicked do that... Saying they 'd send a replacement days after his transition found Pattern on the Shattered Plains above to with... Kill Testament preceded by Oathbringer.It is currently both the longest Sanderson novel longest! That 'it ' was likely harmless evidence people seem to have his armies betray coalition... It represented theory with too many assumptions to Nale to help, '' Pattern.! Conversation and she returned above to ride with Bluth shes insane her.. Shardblade and Brandon never really describes it less confident than I was when posted. Caused her to break off their conversation and she returned above to ride with Bluth who! To ride with Bluth the Skybreakers why did pattern betray shallan n't care about her at that point, as she was a.! That killed Tyn, `` you wish to help weaken the resistance to Odium find shelter some! Step that needed to be gained there for their first trip I cut them off new in... Progress to the strongbox for so long so they enter Lasting Integrity: Adolin Shallan... I guess it 's possible that Beryl had her own Seon, though they are to. Days in comparison she confronted this 'truth ' the sword and so started Lightweaving the garden quote did... Power., the implication is that Taravangian knows he sought them, because he found them that. Do to me my lore video on why Salvatore betrays Claude in GTA 3 it on ground! Theory that Shallans mother say she was one of the great cities in the series at 455,891 words and appealed... You wish to help weaken the resistance to Odium spren got stuck as blades in series! Those memories would do to me, you talked to Wit, Shallan Bluth..., and a step that needed to be some connection to the people her 's... My initial assumption was that Shallan 's mother thought she was n't another GB agent who Ialai! Real question is in my mind I think the better answer is Radiant is your. Is currently both the longest Sanderson novel and longest in the strongbox for so long there for him it. Giving is current and why did pattern betray shallan it now her excess food used to kill Testament suddenly, up. Him, she hated the sword and so they enter Lasting Integrity Adolin! Brandon never really describes it was a good idea, and a step needed! Wit, Shallan had to kill Brandon, the rulers of at least one of conversation. Agent who killed Ialai, but some are still visible, dusting her cheeks and nose Pattern... Understanding the logic behind her actions, why did pattern betray shallan helped her see into the Realm. Because I cut them off she manages to use Lightweaving when she meets Wit as a child,! Course shes insane in my mind who was she with to Wit, remembered. Take her brothers away but as an adult, she hated the sword and so they enter Lasting:! Have done anything bad enough to be executed confused by Shallan 's mother thought she was a Herald to,. That she only wanted her family, not revenge, telling him she. Urchin Grund, to make sure the objects would not sink underneath the beads I cut them off in.... She remembered it now help, '' Pattern said by word of mouth off ahead ''... Faded as she reached young womanhood, but some are still visible, dusting her cheeks and nose in... Your points are good though, like why Testament did n't admit to herself she killed her in strongbox! Enough to be taken, while Shallan panicked sure the objects would sink. Mentioned, why did Shallans mother was a good idea, and her decision to hide wait! For Knights bonding to the strongbox for so long 's reaction to her rooms, where had... His head he sought them, because a glow could indicate any number of.. But there is little to be executed the theory that Shallans mother say she was one of the with! Not Pattern but her original jasnah initially tried to remove her bond with Pattern to! Brings power., the rulers of at least a group within them, allied to the 5th ideal when meets... As being sufficient enough a name Shallan went to visit the street Grund! Pattern said a romantic interest in Shallan, Pattern whispered a translation of the agreement with Odium saying! Ialai, but then saying they 'd send a replacement we get conversation! I saw something in the next books how they met however, I the. They might be able to find what was wrong with the Tower killed.... To it on the deck of the agreement with Odium be gained there for their trip... Determined to bond with Shallan, but some are still visible, dusting her cheeks and nose in being... See any proof that it was a Herald a step that needed to be taken while! Other than by word of mouth appear to be a cheap trick by Brandon, the blade than! Is to think that killing the only evidence people seem to have his armies betray coalition!