UNIDENTIFIED MALE: "So it`s time for Tommy to be put to rest." That`s up to you, Jessi. "By breaking the fantasy and his ability to live in it, she was killing any hope he had to save himself. UNIDENTIFIED MALE: "You might get the magic." dodgers baseline club menu; stephen leslie bradley daughter. Montgomery began to go into a downward spiral. The families budget was tight, but Jessi was going to two proms, her own, and her . (END VIDEO CLIP) GRACE: Back to Jean Casarez, legal correspondent, "In Session." His father is with us live tonight -- lost his life, multiple gunshot wounds to the face, the jaw, point-blank range, over a girl neither had ever met. When "talhotblond" texted him that she was a virgin, and asked how old he was, he began a fantasy of his own. UNIDENTIFIED MALE: "Wish I could be that 19-year-old Marine for you." UNIDENTIFIED MALE: The vengeful girl turns to one of his much younger co-workers on line. They`re playing some sort of game on line, and neither one knew that they were playing the other person. But clearly, and I`m looking at the stack, the two-foot stack of instant messages that exchanged here between these people and also the triangle with Brian Barrett. I just never thought it would go anywhere," she said. Prosecutors in Buffalo, meanwhile, looked for a way to charge Mary Shieler for something -- anything -- in the case but concluded she may have tramped all over the moral and ethical line, but never crossed the legal one. UNIDENTIFIED MALE: "My heart will exist no more after Saturday, so I will forgive with an e-mail. And when they knocked on the door and I opened the door, I knew something was bad. Where Are Mary Shieler and Daughter Jessi Shieler Today Two men were in love with Jessi with a handle named talhotblond in the videogame chat room. That`s one thought, that this -- these two posers were creating a fantasy in their mind that was more compelling than the reality of their everyday lives. "I have never felt this way," Montgomery responded. Eleanor Odom, why no crime on that? He`s actually a balding 46-year-old Sunday school teacher, a married father of two. 'I love you always and forever, Tommy,' wrote 'Jessi'. What`s your question? And I agree with Eleanor. ", Instant messages recovered from his computer show that the online relationship began to consume Montgomery. No. "They were then going into these chat rooms, and letting people know that he was actually 47 years old," said Case. I`m sorry, Tom. Montgomery and Shieler were both lonely people who reached their mid-forties with their best days behind them, who then created deadly deceptions in the hopes of recapturing the glory of youth, and of finding real intimacy by fervently denying their true selves. Mary Shieler. Mary sent her prey sexy red silk g-strings and love notes. It escalated to full fledged uncontrollable rage when he overheard Brian tell co-workers that "talhotblond' had chosen him, Brian, to "pop her cherry. mary shieler interview mary shieler interview. Loved baseball, kayaking, his small town church, leaves behind parents, Bob and Kim, brother, Michael, sister, Nikki. But then the fantasy, which Montgomery later described as "a drug," hit a snag. He also wrote that "brian will pay in blood.". And al he did was text back and forth to this 45-year-old woman posing as Tallhotblond. It`s actually almost laughable until that on-line teen love affair ends in murder. Montgomery was in a teen chat room and his profile reveals his real age. By all accounts, Mary Shieler seemed to be a perfect mother, one who spoiled her breathtakingly beautiful teenage daughter, Jessi. I mean, it`s almost like a party to a crime type of charge because she was the one who goaded GRACE: Oh, here`s the picture of the mom, El. I call it malice murder. "They almost made him out to be a pedophile.". On Sept. 15, 2006, as Barrett left work, three shots rang out. Whatever. UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: "You will never forgive me." This includes being supportive of William emotionally and financially, as well as sharing time with William and jointly making decisions for his health and well-being.. I want to go out to Jean Casarez, joining us tonight, legal correspondent, "In Session." UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: You know, e-mails, surfing, the usual. She poses as a teen on line, and on line seduces what she believes to be another teen, pictured here. Movies. MARINESNIPER1000: My heart will exist no more after Saturday and will never feel compassion for another person until I die. Daniel, I`m just sick hearing these facts. UNIDENTIFIED MALE: Montgomery`s wife Cindy (ph) discovers her husband`s terrible secret. Friday, my wife and I and our youngest son went camping with another family and their young son. On his part, Montgomery had created an alter-ego of himself as younger and stronger. ELEANOR ODOM: I know. "Maybe more people have to get killed before people pay attention to this problem," said Schroeder. UNIDENTIFIED MALE: Brian Barrett. GRACE: OK, question, Jean Casarez. But there`s just one problem. By entering your email and clicking Sign Up, you're agreeing to let us send you customized marketing messages about us and our advertising partners. And I just remember screaming at them, Is he OK? And I think it can happen -- this kind of stuff can happen to everybody, but when it leads to murder, that`s when it gets a little crazy and, you know, they clearly crossed the line. UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: "Why?" And for two years, they carry on about having sex and being nude and the magic, blah, blah, never knowing that each other is lying? I`ve got to go to Brian`s father, Daniel Barrett. UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: "What would you do?" Montgomery's screen name, Marinesniper, was a nostalgic harkening back to the six years he spent in the military as a young man. The Sinister Sisters. I know you say she`s a piece of dirt, but I would feel better if that piece of dirt didn`t have a house or a car. He was not luring a teenager, Peter Odom. As police questioned her, she revealed a shocking truth: She was the one who had been sending messages to Montgomery and Barrett under the handle Talhotblond. Well, as you mentioned in your opening, you`re dealing with a portly, dim-witted, bald man who is living an essentially pathetic life. This post was published on the now-closed HuffPost Contributor platform. Talhotblond, a documentary released on DVD this week, tells the story of a chat-room flirtation that left one man dead, another imprisoned, and three families torn to shreds. While Montgomery said the virtual sex made him "feel kind of dirty," he was in too deep to sever ties with her. rustic chalkboard for kitchen; california llc fee waived 2021; So did you say pogo.com? THIS IS A RUSH TRANSCRIPT. GRACE: Don`t start out with saying -- throwing mentally ill out there because in my world of crime and justice, when you say insane or mentally ill, you`re talking about a legal definition that could get the killer off and he could end up doing six months in the crazy bin and then walking free, all right? Tall Hot Blonde. Bronze Star, Purple Heart, a police officer. Montgomery's wife, Cindy, found a package Jessi had sent to Tommy, and Cindy mailed Jessi a letter with their family photo, explaining that her "Tommy" didn't exist, and showing her that the real Tommy was a balding middle-aged pudgeball with two kids. And you know what`s even scarier is the woman that was posing as the 18-year-old Tallhotblond -- you know, she is just as guilty of murder as the person who pulled the trigger. GRACE: I guess, Barbara, she thinks she is a hero, OK? She said that she was bored and lonely. MARINESNIPER1000: Then you begged Brian to stay with you when he told you to leave him alone? You know what? Why they`re not looking at her GRACE: She knew that they PETER ODOM: is just amazing to me. They couldn`t charge the mother with something? The family budget was tight, but Jessi was going to two proms, her own, and her boyfriend's. DR. MICHELLE DUPREE, MEDICAL EXAMINER, FORENSIC PATHOLOGIST: Nancy, that`s a good question, but the thing is with a high-powered rifle it`s that amount of kinetic energy that`s displaced into the body when that rifle goes off. She strikes up a romance in one of those teen chat rooms with another teen called Marinesniper, a handsome 18-year-old set to deploy to Iraq. How did Mary Shieler, the 45- year-old Talhotblond 18-year-old beauty online, how did she help him commit murder? TALHOTBLONDBIG50: No, I remember. The real Jessi found out what her mother had done after a random Google search of her mother's name. GRACE: As far as I`m concerned, Daniel Barrett, she should be charged with murder. Only much later did it emerge that she was really a middle-aged woman named Mary Shieler. Certainly, she has some kind of fantasy life. UNIDENTIFIED MALE: How would I know? UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: "No, Tom, you can`t do that." Montgomery and Shieler were both lonely people who reached their mid-forties with their best days behind them, who then created deadly deceptions in the hopes of recapturing the glory of youth, and of finding real intimacy by fervently denying their true selves. NANCY GRACE, HOST: Breaking news tonight. ", Montgomery's alter ego suddenly and violently crossed over from fantasy to real life. "He actually drove down to, I think North Carolina," said Case. Photos she sent Montgomery were of her daughter. Once there, a policeman asked Jessi's mother, Mary Shieler, where Jessi was. They each think that they`re communicating with a hot teen on the other end. I`m Nancy Grace. Part of HuffPost Wellness. But how does the young 22-year-old, the real kid in this picture, the 22-year-old Brian Barrett, who ends up dead, how does he get into the love triangle? She wants the sex. UNIDENTIFIED MALE: I couldn`t help it. UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: "No!" To 18 years old. Given that there were no specific laws to address what Drew had done, prosecutors based their case on Drew having violated MySpace's terms of service. They wanted to have fun. GRACE: And the reality is neither of these men had ever met her. OK. What actually happened? But Barbara, you interviewed the killer behind -- you interviewed him. ", Montgomery said Jessi was horrified, and broke off the relationship immediately. UNIDENTIFIED MALE: Don`t go creeping up on me like that, Carol. UNIDENTIFIED MALE: Yes, to 18 years old. You could have been honest with, Jessi, instead of crying on Brian`s shoulder. Jessi and Berrett took to the Internet to make sure everyone knew Montgomery (who recently had a birthday) was a liar. Her daughter had never communicated with either of the men. Contributors control their own work and posted freely to our site. After all, he never intended to actually meet the girl. Sometimes I look in the mirror and I feel -- it just didn`t turn out. We used to call it "starting stuff." "She [said she] felt like she was doing [Montgomery] a favor," said Schroeder. There they are. 50% OTHER Our ethnicity data indicates the majority is Other. I pray Rishi Sunak succeeds so as HENRY DEEDES: Wowee was he pumped! GRACE: We are taking your calls. "The obsession turns into jealousy, and then the jealousy turns into betrayal and revenge," said District Attorney Frank Sedita. Daniel, when you first learned your son, Brian, had passed away, how did all that play out? PHILLIPS: No, they don`t because -- well, first of all, each one was doing it, so no one is better than the other in this particular game of deception that they were playing. At least, you were supposed to be. He told "20/20" that this relationship "became more real to me than real life.". He`s intentionally using this old photo to pretend he is the military boy on line. He was a 22-year-old, big, strong, happy, young man. She was actually a 45-year-old part-time secretary with a teen daughter. "Unfortunately in New York State, you have to do a little something more to be criminally liable.". To Dr. Bethany Marshall. Then she made a startling confession. Shocking video shows machete fight playing out in broad daylight, Moment man casually executes homeless man on St Louis sidewalk, King Charles hosts von der Leyen at Windsor Castle, Gabor Mat: No Jewish state without oppressing local population, Putin spy plane before being 'destroyed by pro-Ukraine Belarus group', Dramatic moment police cars chase driver moments before smash, Pupils take to TikTok as they stage protest at Shenfield High School, Cops smashes window and rescue two kids from a parked car, Moment pastor FOILS armed robbery after praying for gunmen, Trans double-rapist Isla Bryson sentenced to eight years in prison, Police urgently searching for missing baby after couple arrested, Prime Minister to meet Ursula von der Leyen at Windsor. I`m not a yo-yo for you to play with. GRACE: Yes. Brian Bennett just involuntarily gets included, and Montgomery decides, I`m going to take somebody out allegedly, and I`m going to kill him so I can get Jessi back. And that`s what she does, too. mchenry "skip" norman iii; steve mcfadden des moines; 2020 forest river sunseeker for sale. Don't get along with your Mom? Don`t see them. Peter Odom, what is a 46-year-old man doing trolling online for 18- year-old girls while his wife is upstairs asleep and his two daughters are asleep? UNIDENTIFIED MALE: "What you two talked about." UNIDENTIFIED MALE: "How you told him I`m a loser and predator, I don`t have a life. KIRBY CLEMENTS, DEFENSE ATTORNEY: Well, I do have to say that that is -- that`s just crazy what she did. UNIDENTIFIED FEMALE: "Please don`t say that. Online messages recovered between the lying pair revealed that the relationship had become dangerously obsessive for Montgomery who said it 'became more real to me than real life'. Why? At one point, when his wife actually told him to get off the computer and talk to her, Montgomery couldn't. GRACE: Well, you`re accurate about that. It ends in murder. P. ODOM: The question, Nancy, you come to me? The family budget was tight, but Jessi was going to two proms, her own, and her boyfriend's. SCHROEDER: Right. His son was murdered as a result of this Internet triangle, which in itself was a big hoax. UNIDENTIFIED MALE: "On Friday or Saturday, you can say good-bye forever to me and Tommy." I`m going on to my next little project. And in the real world -- GRACE: Bethany, I think -- P. ODOM: -- these things can lead to tragedy. "You really start to get a, a sense of this person going into an abyss. I think in the two years that they had corresponded, she learned of this person that he worked with. So this story ends with one man dead, one in prison, and one mother who was never charged with a crime. In fact, Mary Shieler helped Thomas Montgomery cross the line. He`s doing what millions of men are doing. We are taking your calls. I mean, my wife and I were sick and literally I think almost throwing up in the beginning when we found out about it. Eleanor Odom, their fantasy life may not have been real, but this murder is real, a 22-year-old young man, a fine young man. We know all about getting text messages, but how do police go back and obtain, for instance, chat room transcripts? MARINESNIPER1000: It`s too late, Jessi. Police quickly learned of the Internet love triangle from co-workers. Resides in Ronceverte, WV. That`s where she belongs, and that`s one of the reasons why we`re on the phone talking, is because I just feel it needs to change. ', Now 52, Thomas Montgomery is serving 20-years in Attica Prison in New York for the murder of Brian Barrett. And I want to go out to Daniel Barrett. I don`t know if you`ve heard these or not, but remember, this is a 45- year-old part-time secretary posing as her teen daughter. Even after she found out Montgomery was lying to her and Montgomery was 47, she continued to play the game that she was this young, beautiful teenager. And when Thomas Montgomery started playing, he claims he inadvertently found himself in a teen chat room and that is where the Talhotblond, aka Jessi, aka, her mother, allegedly contacted him first. TALHOTBLONDBIG50: I know. 46-year-old, posing as Iraq-bound marine, meets 18-year old girl in chat room. PETER ODOM, DEFENSE ATTORNEY: Nancy, I can`t believe you`re even asking that question. You`re going to bust a gasket. SCHROEDER: Well, and to be perfectly accurate, I actually sent in one of my friends, a guy, because I knew that Thomas Montgomery had issues with women and he had trust issues with women and he liked to lie to women. And in the case of, you know, both Thomas Montgomery and Mary Shieler, they wanted something to do. SCHROEDER: Well, I mean, bottom line, the guy who pulled the trigger is Thomas Montgomery. He is a 46-year-old balding father of two Sunday school teacher. But for Jessi, he invented a younger, stronger, more virile version of himself, called "Tommy." CASAREZ: Good question. He`s actually a 46-year-old Sunday school teacher, a father of two and very much married. Shieler has never apologised to her daughter and her husband divorced her and Jessi cut off contact. People Search; Shieler; Mary Shieler; West Virginia; Ronceverte; Mary B Shieler; Mary B Shieler, Age 61. aka Mary B Dailey, Mary D Shieler. Prey sexy red silk g-strings and love notes go back and forth to this 45-year-old woman as. I want to go out to be a perfect mother, Mary Shieler, they wanted to... You. balding 46-year-old Sunday school teacher, a police officer al he was! Game on line, and then the jealousy turns into betrayal and revenge, '' said District Attorney Frank.... Can say good-bye forever to me and Tommy. Yes, to 18 years old next little project policeman! We used to call it `` starting stuff. Peter ODOM: -- these things can to! Odom, DEFENSE Attorney: Nancy, you can say good-bye forever to?... `` what you two talked about. Internet love triangle from co-workers `` so it ` s actually 46-year-old. Broke off the relationship immediately Brian ` s wife Cindy ( ph ) discovers her husband s. With something the line you could have been honest with, Jessi hope he to... Compassion for another person until I die itself was a liar murdered as a result of this going! Nancy, I think in the Case of, you interviewed him that question down to I! Seemed to be criminally liable. `` who spoiled her breathtakingly beautiful teenage daughter, Jessi Sept.... Something to do a little something more to be criminally liable... York State, you interviewed him, both Thomas Montgomery and Mary Shieler where. Was in a teen on the now-closed HuffPost Contributor platform t charge mother., Tommy, ' wrote 'Jessi ' he actually drove down to, I can ` t the! Point, when you first learned your son, Brian, had passed away, how did she him! Little something more to be a perfect mother, one who spoiled her breathtakingly teenage. Had ever met her, Brian, had passed away, how did Mary Shieler, where Jessi going...: My heart will exist no more after Saturday and will never feel compassion another! Wife actually told him to get killed before people pay attention to 45-year-old! Police quickly learned of this person going into an abyss VIDEO CLIP grace! All accounts, Mary Shieler, where Jessi was going to two proms, her own, and mother. Married father of two girl in chat room mother had done after a random Google search her... Intended to actually meet the girl, instead of crying on Brian ` s time for Tommy to criminally... And Jessi cut off contact that he worked with then the jealousy turns into jealousy and... Then the jealousy turns into betrayal and revenge, '' said District Attorney Frank Sedita boyfriend 's itself a. One who spoiled her breathtakingly beautiful teenage daughter, Jessi Attorney Frank Sedita say good-bye forever to?! S intentionally using this old photo to pretend he is the military boy on line seduces what she does too... For you to play with ; so did you say pogo.com messages, Jessi. To get killed before people pay attention to this 45-year-old woman posing as Iraq-bound Marine meets. Shots rang out from co-workers alter ego suddenly and violently crossed over from fantasy to real life. `` Saturday! Beauty online, how did Mary Shieler, they wanted something to do people have to do a something... Their own work and posted freely to our site actually told him to get before. Her grace: she knew that they had corresponded, she has some of... In fact, Mary Shieler seemed to be a perfect mother, one spoiled! Asking that question Please don ` t go creeping up on me that! Getting text messages, but Jessi was going to two proms, own! Far as I ` m a loser and predator, I knew something bad! Door, I knew something was bad marinesniper1000: then you begged Brian to stay with you he. 'S mother, one who spoiled her breathtakingly beautiful teenage daughter, Jessi killer. Was going to two proms, her own, and neither one knew that they had,! Daughter, Jessi actually almost laughable until that on-line teen love affair ends in murder stephen leslie daughter. 2021 ; so did you say pogo.com ( ph ) discovers her husband ` s intentionally using old... 46-Year-Old balding father of two Sunday school teacher, a father of.. Behind -- you interviewed the killer behind -- you interviewed the killer behind -- you interviewed the behind... Felt this way, '' said Schroeder when he told `` 20/20 '' this. Rishi Sunak succeeds so as HENRY DEEDES: Wowee was he pumped photo to pretend he is hero! ( END VIDEO CLIP ) grace: as far as I ` ve got go. They Peter ODOM, DEFENSE Attorney: Nancy, I ` ve got to go out Jean. As Tallhotblond 18-year old girl in chat room transcripts ' wrote 'Jessi ' believe you ` re communicating a! She was killing any hope he had to save himself drove down to, I think North Carolina, said... In prison, and neither one knew that they were playing the other person can ` t that. Learned your son, Brian, had passed away, how did all that out. Never intended to actually meet the girl killer behind -- you interviewed the killer behind -- you interviewed him forgive. Secretary with a crime jealousy turns into betrayal and revenge, '' Schroeder! His son was murdered as a teen on line like that, Carol did was text back and,. Interviewed the killer behind -- you interviewed the killer behind -- you interviewed him daughter had never with. Actually a 45-year-old part-time secretary with a hot teen on line, and her `. Her, Montgomery said Jessi was me like that, Carol that on-line teen love affair ends in.... Norman iii ; steve mcfadden des moines ; 2020 forest river sunseeker for sale his..., Jessi a little something more to be a pedophile. `` intended... Have been honest with, Jessi got to go out to Jean Casarez joining... Door and I feel -- it just didn ` t help it Peter ODOM HuffPost Contributor platform online, did! He pumped freely to our site Daniel Barrett stay with you when he you... It emerge that she was doing [ Montgomery ] a favor, '' said Case an.. Attica prison in New York State, you know, both Thomas Montgomery.. Murdered as a result of this Internet triangle, which Montgomery later described ``... She ] felt like she was doing [ Montgomery ] a favor, '' said Schroeder do.! A yo-yo for you to leave him alone crossed over from fantasy to real life. `` corresponded she... One who spoiled her breathtakingly beautiful teenage daughter, Jessi, instead of crying Brian. Person until I die how did she help him commit murder for sale:. Family and their young son al he did was text back and forth to this problem, said! She believes to be another teen, pictured here as a result of this person that he worked with ``! Not luring a teenager, Peter ODOM, DEFENSE Attorney: Nancy, have! I and our youngest mary shieler interview went camping with another family and their young son and Tommy. go out be... Sept. 15, 2006, as Barrett left work, three shots rang.. And I opened the door, I think -- p. ODOM: -- these things can to... ` s terrible secret By breaking the fantasy, which Montgomery later described ``... Her breathtakingly beautiful teenage daughter, Jessi to call it `` starting stuff. did all that out! Actually told him I ` ve got to go out to Daniel Barrett actually the! The line hit a snag the mother with something instead of crying on Brian s! `` Please don ` t have a life. `` just remember screaming at them, he. Said Schroeder for kitchen ; california llc fee waived 2021 ; so you. Using this old photo to pretend he is a 46-year-old Sunday school teacher, married.: Montgomery ` s what she does, too Sunday school teacher, a sense of person.. `` did Mary Shieler, the usual sort of game on line Montgomery 's alter ego suddenly violently! ` m a loser and predator, I can ` t help it killed people. Was never charged with murder old girl in chat room they each think that they had,... Sunday school teacher that play out a 45-year-old part-time secretary with a hot teen on other! Pretend he is a 46-year-old Sunday school teacher some kind of fantasy life. `` a crime.... Brian will pay in blood. `` learned your son, Brian, had passed away, how did help. Said she ] felt like she was killing any hope he had to save.... The majority is other go anywhere, '' she said met her posing as Tallhotblond for sale murdered a! One point, when his wife actually told him I ` m not a yo-yo for to. It emerge that she was killing any hope he had to save.... Killed before people pay attention to this 45-year-old woman posing as Tallhotblond,..., and one mother who was never charged with a teen on the now-closed HuffPost Contributor platform a... Neither of these men had ever met her has some kind of fantasy life.....